The question "Are amendments laws?" may seem simple enough to answer but it opens up an interesting conversation about what actual laws are in our political and legal systems. Let's take a look at the Constitution; Constitutional Laws, and amendments.
If you've ever asked if amendments are laws, you're not the only one. This question often arises in discussions on constitutional rights, change in laws and operation of governments. In this blog, we're going to explore what amendments are and how they work as well as whether they count as "laws" in the typical sense.
What is Constitution and Constitutional Laws?
Constitution is what we can say essentially a legal document that a state can use to indicate the basic legal document of the state. Its supremacy is provided in the Constitution as a legal document and in principle because it establishes the way a state government will operate; limits, powers, functions of institutions; rights and freedoms of individuals in the state. Think of it as the top rule book, the very foundational and comprehensive legal document from which all legal principles flow. Consequently, constitutional laws are those laws that provide meaning and make specific the meaning in functional laws relative to constitutional provisions, and these laws are the nation's highest form of law.
What is Amendments?
For example, in the United States, the First Amendment guarantees freedom of speech, while the Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery.
Are Constitutional Amendments Laws?
Answer: Yes, amendments are laws.
Constitutional amendments are laws, but they are a special category of laws. They are not ordinary legislative acts passed by a simple majority. Instead, they often require a more complex process, such as:
-
A supermajority vote in the legislature
-
Approval by a certain number of states or provinces
-
Referendums or special constitutional conventions
Once an amendment is adopted, it becomes parts of the constitution and carries the same authority as any other constitutional provision—which means it has legal force and must be followed by courts and government bodies.
Why the Confusion between Amendments and Laws?
Many people confuse amendments with ordinary laws because both affect our legal rights and obligations. However, while both are legal rules, amendments change the foundational structure or principles of law, whereas ordinary laws deal with specific issues like traffic rules, taxes, or business regulations.
The Constitutional Aspect of whether the amendments are laws or no?
In Indian Constitution as per the Article 368, “Parliament may in exercise of its constituent power amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any provision of this Constitution...”
The Supreme Court of India has repeatedly upheld that constitutional amendments, once passed under Article 368, become part of the Constitution and carry full legal authority.
The Nuance: "Law" in Specific Legal Contexts
It is important to remember that in the context of certain legal or academic conversations, especially in particular jurisdictions (India), debates have arisen over the applicability of the word "law" in certain articles of the Constitution (which refer to ordinary legislative power) when considering constitutional amendments that were enacted via the constituent power of Parliament. However, in those discussions, the debate was as to the limits of judicial review or certain procedural issues, and not on the question of whether an amendment – once properly enacted – is part of the supreme law of the land. For all intents and purposes, constitutional amendments are law – and the highest form of law.
Conclusion
In summary we can say that the Yes, amendments are Laws. While they differ from ordinary laws in process and authority, their impact is far greater. Amendments reflect societal progress, correct past injustices, and ensure that the constitution remains a living document that adapts over time.
Whether you're a student, a legal enthusiast, or just someone curious about how laws work, understanding the role of amendments helps you grasp the deeper workings of democracy and constitutional governance. So yes—amendments are laws, and they matter more than most.
FAQs About Amendments as Laws
Q1: Can an amendment be illegal?
A: If it follows the proper procedure, it's legal. However, courts can review amendments for violating fundamental principles like human rights.
Q2: Can ordinary laws override constitutional amendments?
A: No. Constitutional amendments always take precedence over regular laws.
Q3: How are amendments passed?
A: This varies by country but usually requires a more rigorous process than regular legislation.
Note: Here, in this article title "Are Amendments Laws? | Are Amendments Considered Laws? Explained", I have tried to explore and answer this mentioned below frequently asked queries:
Are Amendments Laws?
Are Amendments Considered Laws?
What does as amended mean in law?
Is the constitutional amendment a law in UPSC?
Is a Constitution a law or not?
What is the amendment in simple terms?
